Resource Center: What We've Learned
Why Social Media Can Damage an Injury Claim
After an accident, posting a photo, checking in somewhere, or sharing an update about your recovery may seem harmless. But if you are pursuing a personal injury claim, your social media activity can become evidence.
Insurance companies, defense attorneys, and others involved in a personal injury case may examine publicly available social media posts for information that could be relevant to your injuries, your activities, your recovery, or your account of what happened. A post that seems innocent to you may be interpreted very differently when it is viewed in the context of a legal claim.
That does not mean you need to disappear from social media after an accident. It does mean you should understand the potential consequences of what you post, comment on, share, or delete.
Get Started Today
How Can Social Media Affect a Personal Injury Claim?
Social media can become relevant to an injury claim because it can provide photographs, videos, comments, location information, activity updates, and other evidence about what you were doing before and after an accident.
For example, imagine that you are claiming a serious shoulder injury after a Maine car accident. You later post a photograph from a family gathering in which you appear to be lifting a child. The photograph may not tell the full story. Perhaps you were experiencing significant pain, could only lift the child briefly, or had another person help you. But without that context, an insurance company could argue that the photograph is inconsistent with the severity of your injury.
The same issue can arise with posts about travel, exercise, recreation, work, social activities, or even seemingly casual comments about how you are feeling.
Social media evidence can be particularly important in personal injury litigation because it may be used to compare what someone says about an injury with what that person appears to be doing online. The American Bar Association has noted that social media can contain evidence relating to physical or emotional injuries, photographs and videos, post-accident statements, and other information potentially relevant to a legal claim.
Get Started Today
What Should You Avoid Posting After an Accident?
There is no single list of posts that will damage every personal injury claim. Context matters. But several categories deserve particular caution.
1. Photos or Videos Showing Physical Activity
Photographs and videos can create questions about the extent of an injury.
That could include posts showing you:
- Exercising or participating in sports
- Hiking, skiing, boating, or recreational activities
- Lifting or carrying objects
- Attending social events
- Traveling
- Working or performing physical tasks
- Participating in activities you have said your injuries prevent you from doing
The problem is not necessarily that the activity proves you were uninjured. Recovery is rarely an all-or-nothing process. Someone may be capable of doing one activity while still experiencing significant limitations.
The concern is that a photograph or video can provide an incomplete snapshot that may be taken out of context.
2. Comments About Your Injuries or Recovery
Be careful about making casual statements about how you feel.
A post saying that you are “doing great,” for example, could potentially be presented alongside medical records or other evidence to suggest that your injuries are less serious than you claim.
The opposite can also create problems. Statements that exaggerate your symptoms, speculate about your prognosis, or make accusations about another person can complicate an otherwise straightforward claim.
Your social media account is not the appropriate place to document your legal case.
3. Posts About the Accident Itself
It is understandable to want to tell friends and family what happened after a serious accident. But detailed public descriptions of the accident can create unnecessary risks.
You may remember some details incorrectly. You may speculate about who was responsible. You may describe events differently from what later appears in a police report, medical record, witness statement, or other evidence.
Even if you believe your version is completely accurate, there is little benefit to publicly discussing the details of a pending or potential claim.
4. Posts About Travel, Vacations, or Social Activities
A vacation photograph does not necessarily mean that you are not injured.
Nevertheless, an insurance company or defense attorney may look at photographs or posts showing travel or recreational activity and ask questions about whether those activities are consistent with the limitations you have reported.
The important point is not that injured people must stay home. Social media rarely provides enough context to explain the difference between appearing active and actually being fully recovered.
5. Comments About the Insurance Company or Your Case
Avoid publicly discussing settlement negotiations, communications with an insurance company, legal strategy, or conversations with your attorney.
You should also avoid posting about how much money you expect to receive or how you intend to use a potential settlement.
Your personal injury claim should be handled through the appropriate legal and insurance channels—not through Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, or other social platforms.
Can an Insurance Company Look at Your Social Media?
Potentially, yes.
Insurance companies increasingly have access to large amounts of information from outside sources.
The National Association of Insurance Commissioners notes that insurers may collect and use unstructured data—including text, images, videos, and sounds from social media postings—in areas such as claim settlement.
This does not mean that every insurer will investigate every claimant’s social media activity, but it reinforces why you should think carefully about what you make publicly available after an accident.
A common misconception is that putting an account on private makes everything posted there completely protected from scrutiny. Privacy settings can limit who can see content, but they do not necessarily prevent relevant social media information from becoming part of a legal dispute.
Courts have permitted discovery of social media information when it is relevant to issues in litigation, and privacy settings do not automatically place potentially relevant evidence beyond the scope of discovery.
That is one reason it is important to think carefully about social media from the beginning of an injury claim.
Get Started Today
What About Private Social Media Accounts?
Courts have recognized that social media content may be relevant and discoverable when it relates to issues in a case. At the same time, courts have also rejected overly broad requests for unrestricted access to private social-media accounts.
The question is generally whether the information sought is relevant to the issues involved in the dispute.
If information from a private account is relevant to a personal injury claim, questions may arise about whether that information must be disclosed or produced during the legal process. The precise rules depend on the circumstances of the case.
The safest approach is not to assume that changing your privacy settings makes potentially relevant information disappear.
Instead, discuss your social media accounts with your attorney and follow their guidance about preserving and managing relevant information.
Should You Delete Social Media Posts After an Accident?
Deleting, altering, or concealing potentially relevant evidence can create its own problems. Social media information may be subject to preservation obligations once litigation is reasonably anticipated, and attorneys have an obligation to address the preservation of potentially relevant evidence with clients.
This is an important distinction:
Stopping yourself from making new posts is very different from deleting old posts.
If you have already posted something that concerns you, do not panic and do not attempt to clean up your account on your own. Tell your attorney what you posted and let your attorney advise you about what should happen next.
What Should You Do With Social Media After an Injury?
If you have been injured and may pursue a personal injury claim, consider these practical steps:
- Think before you post. Avoid discussing the accident, your injuries, your claim, or your recovery publicly.
- Do not post photographs or videos that could be misunderstood. This is particularly important when they show physical activity.
- Do not speculate about fault. Leave questions about legal responsibility to the evidence and the appropriate legal process.
- Do not delete potentially relevant posts. Speak with your attorney first.
- Tell your attorney about your social media accounts. This can help your attorney identify potential evidence and avoid surprises later.
- Ask family and friends to be careful about posting photographs of you. You cannot always control what other people upload or tag.
- Be consistent and truthful. Your social media activity should not be used to create a different version of your life than the one reflected in your medical records and other evidence.
The goal isn’t to make you afraid to use social media. It is to prevent an informal online post from becoming an unintended piece of evidence in your injury claim.
Social Media Can Be Especially Important After a Maine Car Accident
After a car accident, you may already have substantial evidence about what happened, including police reports, photographs, vehicle damage, medical records, witness accounts, and insurance communications.
The National Association of Insurance Commissioners recommends documenting important information following an automobile accident, including the accident location, road conditions, witnesses, photographs, and other details that may help establish what happened.
Social media can become another source of information that insurers or opposing counsel may examine.
If you were injured in a Maine automobile accident, VBK Law’s Maine Car Accident Lawyers page provides additional information about investigating crashes, documenting injuries, dealing with insurance companies, and pursuing compensation.
For someone injured in a motorcycle crash, social media may also intersect with disputes about the severity of injuries or the circumstances of the collision. See Maine Motorcycle Accident Lawyers for more information about motorcycle injury claims.
Truck accident claims can involve particularly serious injuries and complex investigations involving commercial vehicles, multiple parties, and substantial insurance coverage. Learn more on VBK’s Maine Truck Accident Lawyers page.
More broadly, VBK Law’s Maine Personal Injury Lawyers page explains the types of injury claims the firm handles and why early investigation and evidence preservation can matter.
What If You Have Already Posted Something?
Do not assume that one social media post has ruined your injury claim.
Consider a photograph, comment, or video in the context of the entire case. For example, an image of someone walking does not establish that the person has no injury. A vacation photograph does not necessarily show that someone was physically capable of working full time. And a brief comment about feeling better does not necessarily tell the complete story of a person’s medical condition.
The important question is how the available evidence fits together.
If you have already posted something that concerns you, the best response is generally to stop posting about the case and tell your attorney what happened. Do not delete or alter the material without legal guidance.
A Better Rule: Assume Your Social Media May Be Seen
If you are pursuing a personal injury claim, one practical rule is worth remembering:
If you would not want an insurance adjuster, defense attorney, or judge to see it, think carefully before posting it.
That does not mean every post will become evidence or that you need to stop using social media altogether. It means recognizing that social media is no longer entirely separate from the legal process.
At VBK Law, our Maine personal injury attorneys approach injury claims with careful attention to evidence, medical documentation, insurance communications, and the circumstances surrounding the injury. If you have been injured because of someone else’s negligence, an early conversation with an attorney can help you understand what steps may protect your claim.
Speak with a Maine Personal Injury Attorney
This resource is provided for general informational purposes and does not constitute legal advice. Every personal injury claim is different. If you have questions about your particular situation, consult a qualified Maine attorney.
